"To me, these gold-bordered cards are perfectly fine, because they were printed by Wizards, and you aren't playing these at sanctioned events (unless your LGS supports EDH as a FNM format). In particular, I feel that the first point is, and should be the distinguishing factor."
"It is strange, I am not a fan of proxies but these are somehow different to me. If someone in my playgroup asked about using one I would be all for it."
"They're effectively just really nice looking proxies. If someone played them against me, my reaction would be the same as with any other proxied card - "hey dude, thanks for playing even though you don't necessarily consider it a good idea to drop $150 on Gaea's Cradle or $80 on Wasteland. Glad you could join us." That said, anyone who hates proxies yet allows these is a hypocrite."
Personligen så ser jag i slutändan helst att folk spelar med riktiga kort, men jag kan inte riktigt argumentera för exakt varför, det bara känns rätt på något vis. Jag skulle dock inte alls ha någonting emot om någon spelade med proxies så länge som de är snyggt gjorda (gärna inte en hel lek fylld med post-it lappar liksom), och WCD korten är ju riktigt snygga proxies om inte annat!
Vad tycker ni? WCD kort och proxies, bu eller bä? :]
Squee tucked the warm ball in his pocket and slipped a pebble in its place. ‘Glok,' he mumbled, and hid.